Review: The Van Apfel Girls Are Gone by Felicity McLean


Title: The Van Apfel Girls Are Gone

Author: Felicity McLean

Published: April 1st 2019, 4th Estate

Status: Read May 2019 – courtesy HarperCollins/ Netgalley


My Status:

‘Don’t you know? The Van Apfel girls are gone.’

In the summer of 1992, sisters Hannah, Cordelia, and Ruth Van Apfel vanished from an outdoor school concert. Twenty years later, Tikka Molloy still imagines she might see the Van Apfel girls again, and when she returns to her family home to support her ill sister, she cannot help but reexamine the events of that fateful summer.

“We lost all three girls that summer. Let them slip away like the words of some half-remembered song,…”

Perhaps best described as suburban gothic, part enigmatic mystery, part haunting coming of age tale, The Van Apfel Girls Are Gone is told largely from the perspective of Tikka at age 11.

Tik is a charming narrator, and McLean has struck just the right balance between precociousness and naivety. With both the wisdom and innocence of childhood, she relates her experiences of the summer, from scorching days poolside, to news reports of Lindy Chamberlain’s vindication, to the secrets she and her sister, Laura, kept for their friends, Hannah, Cordelia, and Ruth Van Apfel.

“For so long we’d been haunted by those girls. Since the moment they first disappeared. We were the ones left behind, Laura and I. Defined by what was long gone. And if not that, then what? Who should we be?”

With adult hindsight, Tikka has some regrets about that summer. It’s a large part of the reason she can’t let go, and McLean thoughtfully explores the way in which Tikka was, and continues to be, affected by the missing Van Apfel girls.

It’s Cordelia, the beautiful, enigmatic middle sister that looms largest in Tikka’s mind, the target of her father’s zealotry, the subject of childish innuendo, admired and envied in almost equal measure, despite being just thirteen the year she vanished. McLean’s portrayal of the Van Apfel girls is limited, largely filtered through Tik’s unsophisticated viewpoint, but is still compelling.

“We ran elaborate underwater handstand competitions In the Van Apfel pool that day. First round, second round, best of the best. Our skinny legs stabbing at the sky like the bows of some demented orchestra.”

I have to admit a part of the appeal of this story is the nostalgia it evokes for me. Tik’s experience of childhood is not that much different than my own- handstand competitions in the pool, thongs sticking to melting bitumen roads, Sunnyboy’s dug out of the freezer, scaring ourselves half to death with seances during sleepovers. I even had pet mice, and a river ran through the bush at the bottom of my street.

“There was before and there was ever after.”

It’s only fair that prospective readers know that the fate of the Van Apfel girls remains largely unresolved, for me, it wasn’t really an issue. An atmospheric and poignant novel, I thought The Van Apfel Girls Are Gone was an engaging and mesmeric debut from Felicity McLean.

Read an Excerpt


Available to purchase via

HarperCollins AU I Booko I Booktopia I Book Depository I Amazon AU

Algonquin I Amazon US

I Waterstones I Amazon UK

US Cover I UK Cover

7 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. Kate W
    May 09, 2019 @ 12:42:12

    I think you enjoyed this one more than I did but agree the moments about childhood were well done. Also agree that the lack of resolution doesn’t detract from the story – in fact, I think if it had been ‘solved’ it would have weakened the portrayal of adult Tikka.

    Liked by 1 person


  2. vvb32
    May 09, 2019 @ 14:53:49

    Certainly has got me curious.

    Liked by 1 person


  3. tonyalee
    May 11, 2019 @ 00:37:36

    This is the first time I’m hearing about this one – and I’m intrigued for sure!

    Liked by 1 person


  4. emmasbibliotreasures
    May 12, 2019 @ 17:53:03

    Wonderful review. I have this waiting to be read and I’m even more excited to read it after this thoughtful review.

    Liked by 1 person


  5. Trackback: It’s Monday! What Are You Reading? | book'd out
  6. Verushka, an editor (@SydneyEditor1)
    May 13, 2019 @ 22:02:45

    You know, I tried reading this, but really couldn’t get into it. I still can’t figure out why. I think I may need some distance from it before trying it again.

    Liked by 1 person


I want to know what you think! Your comments are appreciated.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s