Review: Lone Wolf by Jodi Picoult


Title: Lone Wolf

Author: Jodi Picoult

Published: Allen & Unwin March 2012

Synopsis: Edward Warren, 23, has been living in Thailand for five years, a prodigal son who left his family after an irreparable fight with his father, Luke. But he gets a frantic phone call: His dad lies comatose in a NH hospital, gravely injured in the same accident that has also injured his younger sister Cara. Cara, 17, stll holds a grudge against her brother, since his departure led to her parents’ divorce. In the aftermath, she’s lived with her father – an animal conservationist who became famous after living with a wild wolf pack in the Canadian wild. It is impossible for her to reconcile the still, broken man in the hospital bed with her vibrant, dynamic father.  With Luke’s chances for recovery dwindling, Cara wants to wait for a miracle. But Edward wants to terminate life support and donate his father’s organs. Is he motivated by altruism, or revenge? And to what lengths will his sister go to stop him from making an irrevocable decision?

Status: Read from March 23 to 26, 2012 — I own a copy (Courtesy Allen & Unwin)

My Thoughts:

Lone Wolf has all the elements I would expect from Jodi Picoult, controversy, ethical conflict, and courtroom drama. Luke Warren is severely injured in a car accident and lies comatose in hospital. His estranged son returns from Thailand after a five year absence to be at his father’s bedside, to the disgust of his younger sister. Cara Warren is seventeen, too young to make medical decisions for her father and resents Edwards authority. When Edward makes the painful choice to discontinue life support, Cara accuses him of wanting to kill their father and seeks a legal order to stop him. The emotional battle will reveal the secrets of the broken family as the siblings each seek to honour their father in their own ways.

The story of Lone Wolf unfolds through alternating chapters from the perspectives of the main characters, Luke, his children Edward and Cara, ex wife Georgie and briefly, Helen, the court appointed Public Guardian.
Cara, who was also in the accident, is devastated by her fathers injuries and unable to rationally consider his medical status. Having lived with her father for the past five years she feels she should have the right to choose the path of her father’s care and with the naivete of youth is determined that life support be continued indefinitely, convinced a miracle will occur. Cara deeply resents Edward, blaming him for the break up of their parents marriage and is irrationally convinced that Edward hates Luke and wants him dead.
Edward left home at eighteen after a fight with his father, allowing his mother and sister to believe it had to do with revealing his sexuality. Luke’s motives were actually more complicated and he has kept them hidden by keeping his distance from the family. Returning home forces him to face the consequences of his estrangement.
Georgie is torn between the needs of her children, her ex husband and her new family. She wants to support both Cara and Edward but the decision they face doesn’t allow her to.
While a large part of the novel concerns the issues of the withdrawal of life support, organ donation and medical guardianship it is also about who Luke and his wolves, though Luke remains unconscious during the entire book. Luke is a wildlife biologist with an obsession for wolves. His unusual study methods including living with a wild wolves in Canada and feeding from raw carcasses with his captive pack. The information Picoult shares about the wolves is interesting and she neatly relates it to her characters but Luke’s behaviour can’t help but strike you as a little bizarre. I also cynically wonder if Picoults choice of wolves to feature in this novel comes from the commercial appeal of their paranormal counterparts, particularly as Lone Wolf has a YA slant.
For me, there was nothing terribly bad about Lone Wolf but neither was there anything remarkable. I felt at times that Picoult favoured melodrama over real passion, the issues seemed to be little more than a surface debate and the plot was too contrived. Unfortunately the characters also largely left me cold. I was sympathetic, but Cara acted half her age and Georgie just sort of flapped around ineffectually. Of the three I liked Edward the most but there were a few incidents he was involved in that didn’t work for me as plot points.

I think fans of Picoult will be left distinctly underwhelmed by Lone Wolf but its an accessible title for a younger audience and a reasonably quick read as the typeset is quite large. The marketing drive is certainly quite extensive so I would expect that despite my opinion Lone Wolf will quickly appear on the bestseller lists.


Mari of Bookworm With A View was also reading Lone Wolf at the same time as me and we asked each other a few questions., make sure you pop over to Bookworm With A View  to see how I answered the questions Mari had for me!

Q: Do you think Luke’s obsession with wolves is the sign of a brilliant or damaged mind? What did you think of Luke?

Mari: At the beginning of the novel I enjoyed learning more about wolves but if I’m honest, I lost interest after about 100 pages. He was obsessed with the wolves that it led to issues with the rest of his life. Just when I thought he had lost a connection to reality, my view changed when Cara shares what really happened the night of the accident.

Q: Georgie was torn between her children, do you think she made the right decisions? Should she have done something differently?

Mari: How do I answer this one without sharing too much. I have one child so I can’t begin to understand being torn between two children. That said, there is an incident in the hospital where Georgie chooses to follow of her children… I think I would have made the same decision. Vague enough? If you have read the book you know what I’m referring to.

Q: Edward believes he left to protect his family, do you think Georgie and Luke would have remained together if he had stayed, or was the divorce inevitable?

Mari: When this secret was revealed, in full… I thought wow! If he had talked to his parents his decision may have been completely different. Hind sight 20/20, divorce was most likely the only option for Georgie. It was a strange situation.



Available to Purchase

Australia: @ Allen & Unwin I @Boomerang Books I @Booktopia I @ Amazon (Kindle)

International: @ Amazon US I @ Amazon UK I @Bookdepository

Alternate Covers

3 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. mpartyka
    Mar 31, 2012 @ 06:23:38

    I may have enjoyed this book a little more than you did. I was tired of the wolves though, after just 100 pages.

    My book club had a good discussion though, about end of life and organ donation. Very interesting.

    Thanks for reading/discussing this book with me!



  2. laurelrainsnow
    Mar 31, 2012 @ 07:10:52

    I felt that Luke’s “voice” was intrusive and irrelevant after awhile. I also found Cara very annoying; I’ve known and worked with many teens over the years, so I don’t think we can attribute her attitudes and behavior to her youth.

    I liked Edward the most, too, and while his not sharing the secret before he left put him in a bad light, I can understand why he made that choice.



  3. The Australian Bookshelf
    Apr 04, 2012 @ 19:55:43

    I have always wondered whether i should pick up a book by Jodi Picoult… still not quite convinced yet. Fair review though, Shelleyrae



I want to know what you think! Your comments are appreciated.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s